Differences Between Air Insulated Switchgear (AIS) and Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS)
Modern substations primarily utilize two types of switchgear: Air Insulated Switchgear (AIS) and Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS). AIS relies on air as the insulating medium, while GIS uses SF₆ gas in a sealed environment. Each type has unique advantages suited to different applications. This article highlights the key differences between AIS and GIS substations across five critical aspects.
1. Construction
The primary distinction between AIS and GIS lies in their construction and insulation medium.
- AIS Construction: AIS employs air for insulation, meaning that its electrical components are exposed to the surrounding environment. It consists of circuit breakers, disconnectors, transformers, and other equipment mounted on steel or concrete structures.
- GIS Construction: In contrast, GIS uses SF₆ gas within a fully enclosed metal structure. Its components—such as busbars, circuit breakers, and disconnectors—are housed in sealed, gas-insulated compartments, providing excellent dielectric strength.
Since GIS is completely enclosed, it offers better protection against environmental factors and electromagnetic interference. In contrast, AIS is more exposed, making it vulnerable to external conditions and requiring more frequent maintenance.
2. Space Requirements & Suitable Environments
Space Efficiency
- GIS is significantly more compact than AIS, requiring much less space for installation. This makes it ideal for urban areas, underground substations, industrial facilities, tunnels, and offshore platforms where space is limited.
- AIS requires a larger footprint due to the need for greater air insulation distances. It is better suited for rural and suburban areas, where space is less of a constraint.
Environmental Adaptability
- GIS is well-suited for harsh environments such as coastal regions, deserts, and areas with high humidity due to its sealed design that prevents contamination.
- AIS performs best in moderate climates, as air insulation is more susceptible to humidity, pollution, and extreme temperatures. In highly polluted or humid environments, AIS insulation can degrade, increasing the risk of flashovers and requiring additional maintenance.
3. Safety & Reliability
Both AIS and GIS are designed with safety and reliability in mind, but they differ in how they manage risks.
- GIS Safety: The sealed design of GIS significantly reduces arc flash risks, ensuring better personnel protection and reducing direct exposure to high-voltage components. The use of SF₆ insulation enhances reliability by lowering the risk of dielectric failures.
- AIS Safety: Since AIS is exposed to environmental factors, it is more susceptible to lightning, pollution, and moisture, which increases maintenance requirements and operational risks.
While both switchgear types are built for reliability, GIS generally requires less maintenance and experiences fewer unexpected outages due to its enclosed nature.
4. Scalability & Expansion
Scalability is an important factor when planning future substation expansions or modifications.
- AIS Scalability: AIS substations are relatively easy to expand because they are built in an open-air layout. Adding extra bays, transformers, or switchgear can be done with minimal disruption to existing operations, making AIS a cost-effective choice for utilities planning future expansions.
- GIS Scalability: GIS expansion is more complex due to its compact, modular design. Adding new gas-insulated modules requires specialized handling and can be expensive. However, leading manufacturers like CHINT are developing modular GIS solutions that improve scalability through plug-and-play designs and digital monitoring.
5. Environmental Impact
Environmental considerations are crucial in modern substation design.
- GIS & SF₆ Impact: GIS relies on SF₆ gas, a potent greenhouse gas with a high global warming potential (GWP). Although GIS is designed to prevent leaks, emissions can still occur due to equipment aging or mishandling, contributing to climate change. As a result, manufacturers are researching SF₆-free alternatives using dry air and other eco-friendly gases.
- AIS & Environmental Considerations: AIS has a lower direct environmental impact since it does not use SF₆ gas. However, it requires more land, potentially leading to deforestation or habitat disruption for large installations.
In response to environmental concerns, many power companies and regulators are encouraging SF₆-free technologies, pushing manufacturers to develop greener GIS solutions.
Conclusion
| Factor |
AIS (Air-Insulated Switchgear) |
GIS (Gas-Insulated Switchgear) |
| Insulation Medium |
Air |
SF₆ gas |
| Space Requirement |
Large footprint |
Compact, space-saving |
| Environmental Adaptability |
Best for moderate climates |
Ideal for harsh environments |
| Safety & Reliability |
Higher exposure, requires more maintenance |
Fully enclosed, lower failure rate |
| Scalability |
Easier to expand |
Complex expansion process |
| Environmental Impact |
No SF₆, but large land use |
Uses SF₆, but manufacturers are developing alternatives |
Both AIS and GIS have distinct advantages depending on space constraints, environmental conditions, safety requirements, and future scalability needs. GIS is preferred for compact, high-reliability applications, while AIS is a cost-effective choice where space is not a constraint and environmental exposure is manageable.
As the industry moves toward sustainable solutions, advancements in SF₆-free switchgear technologies will further shape the future of substation design.
Professiona Switchgear supplier and manufacturer
- Zhejiang GONGSHUN Electrical Co.,Ltd (electricgs.com), Our company was founded in the late 1990s, specializing in the production of inflatable cabinets, SF6 inflatable cabinets, and various high and low voltage complete sets of electrical equipment. It has multiple subsidiaries under its jurisdiction, including high-voltage load switch branch, high-voltage circuit breaker branch, high-voltage fuse branch, and technology development branch.Our technical expertise, comprehensive product portfolio and long-term rich experience are helping many customers in need to solve their power problems. We’re happy to help at any time. Whether you need application product advice or technical assistance, our global service team is committed to providing you with the right support. For more technical information about medium voltage earthing switch, feel free to contact us, send an email to gongshun@electric-cn.com
- Our company specializes in producing 12KV-40.5KV series high-voltage electrical products: FZN58, FLN48, FLN36, FZRN25, FZN21, FN18, ZFN16, FN12, FN8, FN7, FN5, XRNT, XRNP, VS1, ZN28, ZW8, ZW32, JN15, GN19, GN22, GN24, GN30, CLXGN15-12, HXGN □ -12, DXG-12 (L), DFW □ -12 high-voltage cable branch box, CLXGN □ -12 (SF6) series inflatable cabinet 12KV and 35KV cable accessories, etc; CLVXP-12 indoor AC high voltage fixed switchgear, CL-SIS-12 compact solid insulated ring main unit, professional assembly Schneider SC6 (SF6) series load switchgear, ABB produced SFG (SF6) series load switchgear and other series products; Distribution and agency of high-voltage load switches and inflatable cabinets produced by Schneider Electric and ABB; Siemens produces the 3AJ1 series of indoor medium voltage vacuum circuit breakers and other related products. The company has a complete range of products and has been operating safely on domestic and international power grids for a long time, receiving unanimous praise from both new and old users. Among them, multiple products such as FZRN25, FN12, FLN36-12, XRNT-12 have been exported to various countries and regions in East Asia, South Asia, Southeast Asia, Africa, and the United States.
