WhatsApp: +8613967773640 Email: gongshun@electric-cn.com
  

Differences Between Metal Enclosed and Metal Clad Switchgear

Metal-Enclosed vs. Metal-Clad Switchgear: Key Differences and Applications

In the realm of electrical power systems, metal-enclosed and metal-clad switchgear are two widely used configurations for medium-voltage applications. While both serve critical roles in power distribution, their designs, functionalities, and areas of application differ significantly. These differences, outlined in the IEC 62271-200 standard, are essential for engineers and professionals to understand when selecting the right equipment for their systems.

This guide delves into the definitions, features, and distinctions between metal-enclosed and metal-clad switchgear, offering insights to help you make an informed decision.

Metal-Enclosed Switchgear

Definition

According to the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), metal-enclosed switchgear consists of electrical distribution or switching equipment housed within a single metal enclosure. This design protects the components from environmental elements such as dust and moisture while ensuring personnel safety by preventing accidental contact with live parts.

Components such as circuit breakers, power fuses, fusible switches, and control and metering devices are housed together without requiring separate compartments, making it a more compact and cost-effective solution.

Features

  • Integrated Design: Houses all components in a shared enclosure, typically made of steel.
  • Space Efficiency: Requires less space compared to more compartmentalized systems.
  • Safety Classification: Classified under AFL for internal arc protection, PI for partitioning, and LSC-2A for loss of service continuity according to IEC 62271-200.
  • Applications: Ideal for systems with smaller loads and lower fault currents, such as those requiring low-voltage power circuit breakers.

Metal-Clad Switchgear

Definition

Metal-clad switchgear, a subset of metal-enclosed systems, features individually compartmentalized components. Each internal element, such as circuit breakers, busbars, and transformers, is enclosed in its own grounded metal compartment. This compartmentalized design enhances safety and reliability by allowing isolated access to individual components without disrupting the entire system.

Features

  • Compartmentalization: Each component is housed separately, minimizing risks and improving safety.
  • Enhanced Safety: Provides additional protection during maintenance or faults.
  • Maintenance Access: Operators can work on specific compartments while other parts of the system remain operational.
  • Safety Classification: Classified under AFLR for internal arc protection, PM for partitioning, and LSC-2B for loss of service continuity according to IEC 62271-200.
  • Applications: Designed for high-demand environments, such as power plants, industrial facilities, utility substations, and mining operations.

Key Differences Between Metal-Enclosed and Metal-Clad Switchgear

Enclosure Configuration

  • Metal-Enclosed: Single enclosure for all components.
  • Metal-Clad: Individual compartments for each component.

Compartmentalization

  • Metal-Enclosed: All components, such as cable connections, circuit breakers, and transformers, are accessible within a single panel.
  • Metal-Clad: Each component is housed in its own compartment, allowing targeted access and maintenance.

Service Continuity

  • Metal-Enclosed (LSC-2A): The busbar or circuit breaker compartment can remain energized when an accessible compartment is opened. However, cable compartments must be grounded before access.
  • Metal-Clad (LSC-2B): Maintains service continuity with separate compartments for switching devices, busbars, and connections, enabling maintenance without disconnecting the entire system.

Fault Current Capacity

  • Metal-Enclosed: Suitable for lower fault currents and smaller electrical loads.
  • Metal-Clad: Designed for higher fault currents, offering better system coordination and fault protection.

Safety

  • Metal-Enclosed: Provides basic protection against accidental contact with live parts.
  • Metal-Clad: Enhanced safety through compartmentalization, reducing exposure to hazardous components during operation and maintenance.

Applications

  • Metal-Enclosed: Best suited for simpler systems, such as low-voltage or medium-voltage setups with smaller transformers.
  • Metal-Clad: Ideal for high-demand, high-load environments where safety and reliability are paramount.

Choosing the Right Switchgear

Selecting between metal-enclosed and metal-clad switchgear depends on several factors, including:

  1. Electrical Load: Metal-enclosed systems are suitable for smaller loads, while metal-clad systems handle higher loads effectively.
  2. Fault Current Levels: Consider the fault current capacity of your system to ensure appropriate protection.
  3. Safety Requirements: For environments requiring higher safety and reliability, metal-clad switchgear is preferable.
  4. Maintenance Needs: Metal-clad systems allow targeted maintenance, while metal-enclosed systems offer quicker overall access.
  5. Space Constraints: Metal-enclosed switchgear requires less space, making it ideal for compact installations.

Conclusion

Both metal-enclosed and metal-clad switchgear serve vital roles in modern electrical systems. Metal-enclosed systems offer cost-effective solutions for low to medium loads, while metal-clad systems provide superior safety and reliability for high-demand environments.

For customized solutions that balance these technologies, consulting an expert like Aktif Elektroteknik can help determine the most suitable option for your specific needs.

Professional Metal-Clad Switchgear supplier and manufacturer 

  1. Zhejiang GONGSHUN Electrical Co.,Ltd (electricgs.com), Our company was founded in the late 1990s, specializing in the production of inflatable cabinets, SF6 inflatable cabinets, and various high and low voltage complete sets of electrical equipment. It has multiple subsidiaries under its jurisdiction, including high-voltage load switch branch, high-voltage circuit breaker branch, high-voltage fuse branch, and technology development branch.Our technical expertise, comprehensive product portfolio and long-term rich experience are helping many customers in need to solve their power problems. We’re happy to help at any time.  Whether you need application product advice or technical assistance, our global service team is committed to providing you with the right support. For more technical information about medium voltage earthing switch, feel free to contact us, send an email to gongshun@electric-cn.com 
  2. Our company specializes in producing 12KV-40.5KV series high-voltage electrical products: FZN58, FLN48, FLN36, FZRN25, FZN21, FN18, ZFN16, FN12, FN8, FN7, FN5, XRNT, XRNP, VS1, ZN28, ZW8, ZW32, JN15, GN19, GN22, GN24, GN30, CLXGN15-12, HXGN □ -12, DXG-12 (L), DFW □ -12 high-voltage cable branch box, CLXGN □ -12 (SF6) series inflatable cabinet 12KV and 35KV cable accessories, etc; CLVXP-12 indoor AC high voltage fixed switchgear, CL-SIS-12 compact solid insulated ring main unit, professional assembly Schneider SC6 (SF6) series load switchgear, ABB produced SFG (SF6) series load switchgear and other series products; Distribution and agency of high-voltage load switches and inflatable cabinets produced by Schneider Electric and ABB; Siemens produces the 3AJ1 series of indoor medium voltage vacuum circuit breakers and other related products. The company has a complete range of products and has been operating safely on domestic and international power grids for a long time, receiving unanimous praise from both new and old users. Among them, multiple products such as FZRN25, FN12, FLN36-12, XRNT-12 have been exported to various countries and regions in East Asia, South Asia, Southeast Asia, Africa, and the United States.